There are so many things I do not understand about The Hunger Games. I am not talking about plot holes — most movies have those and nearly all franchises will develop a few over time. No, I mean foundational stuff. World building. Internal consistency. Are the games meant to be a distraction, like the blood and circuses, or a show of power by a totalitarian government to keep a population in fear? I have always felt as though the films’ answer was “a little of both.” But that makes no sense. A strategy of distraction is different from a strategy of shocking and awing. The books themselves give contradictory answers — psychological control but also a little hope (with the prospect of a winner being rewarded.)
But really, if the point of the games is to keep people compliant, why have an open-ended competition rather than a scripted one? And if the capitol has the kind of wealth needed to create the arena and manipulate global communications, why not just pull a Capricorn One and script the whole thing for the story you want?
These are things I don’t understand about the world-building, but my deeper confusion is not about Panem but our relationship to it. Are these stories supposed to entertain us? Enlighten us? Warn us about totalitarianism and propaganda? Elicit fear and loathing to provoke catharsis? I always feeling a bit of shame, if I am honest, whenever I watch one of these movies. Children being served up for violent deaths for my entertainment makes me feel as though the capitol is correct in their low view of people like me. I guess Suzanne Collins or Francis Lawrence can argue that we are being shown disgusting things that are supposed to disgust us. But our capacity to be endlessly disgusted is not limitless, and the cynic and me wonders whether or not a narrative can be a cautionary tale without the cautionary lesson being loud and clear. And I don’t see a cautionary message here. Totalitarianism is bad. Freedom is better. Slaughtering children is evil. Sacrificing for those we love is good. These are all true message, but do I really need five movies of kids being shot, poisoned, burned, dismembered, and tortured to drive that point home?
Sunrise on the Reaping‘s status as a prequel is doubly problematic here. Like all prequels, it deals with the problem that the larger evil cannot be defeated until some future time when the initial movie for which it is a prequel takes place. At the same time, who wants to watch a movie that ends in defeat? Middle sections of trilogies or serials might have setbacks, but they are transitional parts of larger stories. Prequels are either self-contained stories with endings where evil (temporarily for the franchise but permanently for the characters in that narrative) still prevails. The fact that we know that Katniss is going to grow up to end the Hunger Games doesn’t make watching the deaths of forty-seven other children here any less of a downer.
The comp here is probably Rogue One in the Star Wars universe or Ender’s Shadow in Orson Scott Card’s books. They are slightly less prequels and more like parallel stories that feed into the primary narrative. Yet, if I am honest, I feel as though rather than enriching and enlarging the primary narrative, they act as parasites feeding off our nostalgia for the old story. There is a reason why some songs are the “B” side of a .45 and it it is pretty rare that these expansions do anything more than invoke the positive feelings we have for the principle narrative. The only real exception I can think of might be C.S. Lewis’s The Magician’s Nephew, though that is more of an origin story for Narnia than a prequel to The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe.
Readers will notice — they make even complain — that I have yet to say anything about the film itself. Sunrise of the Reaping is not really that much different from the first Hunger Games. There is a draft, training, the games themselves, the bitter aftermath. Plotwise, we know, of course, what the outcome is going to be. The only real question is whether how that outcome is achieved adds anything to the overall mythopoetics of Panem. It doesn’t. Mckenna Grace and Joseph Zada do a lot of heavy lifting by playing it straight, even if doing so means having to internalize the weight of some trauma in the service of a narrative that has no business asking a serious actor to internalize or manifest such psychological horrors for such a frivolous and superficial narrative.
The best counter argument I have heard to my more cynical reading came from my friend, Jacob Berger, who opined that Plutarch’s (Jesse Plemons) final speech is directed not just at Haymitch but at the audience. The essence of Plutarch’s argument is that living to fight another day is better than dying since there is yet a possibility that our attempts at the right may have ripples and repercussions that we did not intend nor are even conscious of. That’s a very comforting thought. Especially for an audience (or readership) who might be wrestling with despair about how their own world is drifting ever closer to what once seemed ridiculously and implausibly over-the-top in our dystopian fiction. The cynic in me, though, spent enough time on the outskirts of evangelical culture in young adulthood that the “maybe you planted a seed” argument always feels like a crumb thrown at the disillusioned idealist when things do go according to their providential plans.
And yet…just because that speech grates doesn’t mean it isn’t true. In the world of Panem it is and was true. Haymitch’s actions, while not causing the defeat of the capitol nor the cessation of their worst atrocity, were steps in that direction. You don’t even have to claim, as I think this film tries unsuccessfully to claim, that Haymitch was a material or necessary influence on Katniss — that there wouldn’t have been a Katniss without a Haymitch — in order to reject the cynical reading that his actions were rendered meaningless because he could not achieve the outcome he strove for.
Ultimately, then, the only way I could appreciate Sunrise on the Reaping was by framing it as what I have elsewhere called an Ecclesiastes movie. In that most confusing and maddening book from the Old Testament, the prophet laments: “I have seen everything in my days of vanity: There is a just man who perishes in his righteousness, And there is a wicked man who prolongs life in his wickedness.” (7:15)
Ecclesiastes can be a book of great comfort because it confirms that although we have been told many things about God, justice, and the world, our eyes have seen many other things that are hard to square with what we have been taught. But whatever comfort comes from believing, maybe even knowing that justice will eventually prevail, must by necessity be accompanied by a great anguish, a groaning of creation, because the difference between “never” and “not yet” can be virtually impossible to see or believe for those who cannot transcend time, who do not have absolute certainty and conviction that right will prevail one day because it is willed by the power that transcends all others. Zada does a credible job as an actor conveying that Haymitch, the individual character, doesn’t have that conviction and is hence despairing. But the film never conquers the problem that we as audience members cannot share his anguish because we not only have faith that good will prevail eventually, we have certainty of it. We have certainty of it, because we have already seen it. Thus we are separated from his anguish, can only observe it from a distance. That is why, at least for this viewer, for all the carnage, for all the terror, for all the psychological and physical torture on display, Sunrise of the Reaping was an emotionally flat experience, one that could not truly inspire hope or courage because it never escaped, not even for a second, the perfect knowledge of hindsight. When the outcome is already determine, both in the short and long term, what are the stakes?
